Normally I'd agree with you about Jeter, but this year more than the last few he's justified to be on the team. He's hitting .295 with 7 HR and 22 RBI out of the leadoff spot. Barlett just got injured so I'm sure that's cost him some votes, but yeah his stats are off the charts right now.
XI Wiki



But hey, the front runners right now are actually pretty legit for the most part.
