That's kinda what I was expecting, I'm in no way trying to insult Alma here.
My original point was that when you increase damage, you will increase the kill #, so Alma should not discount the extra mobs killed as a reason for doing more damage, but instead should probably consider the fact that the extra mobs killed were because Alma was doing more damage (with Glanz).
They wouldn't be there to hold hate. They'd be there to keep the monk alive by flashing after the mob weaponskills and dumping MP on him.
Again: Unless you have a really, really good backline, mnk/war will die against Mamools. In the absence of said really, really good backline (an assumption that Failure is making), a pld/nin in one of the DD spots can be the difference that keeps said monk alive.
That fact that you both thought/think the paladin(s) would be there to take/hold hate speaks to a fundamental misunderstanding of enmity mechanics and mnk/war's relative strengths and weaknesses in a meritpo situation.
I dont' even remember the last time I went /war. I pull enough hate as it is with /nin.
1. Good backline does not equal clearing all the mobs. Good frontline does. I'm not saying Alma didn't have an amazing healer, maybe Alma even had one of those JP parties with rdm + whm both, who knows. I'm saying that mnk/war does in no way conclude that they were keeping up with the spawn rate. In fact, as I've said like 4 times now, based on # of mobs killed, THERE IS NO WAY THEY WERE KEEPING UP WITH THE SPAWN RATE.
2. We both understand hate and enmity mechanics perfectly fine, thanks. As I said in another post (do you even read them, or pick 1 sentence to reply to?), a pld will never hold hate over a sam/war that wants to tank. A mnk/war will also never hold hate over a sam/war that wants to tank, unless the monk is actively trying to with vokes/etc.
So again, I'm not saying anything at all about Alma's backline. I'm saying their DD was not high enough to kill all the Mamools. I am also saying that a decent/average party can pull 20k/hr at that camp without clearing all the mamools. Pertaining to the actual topic, I am saying 2 things:
1. KParse is inaccurate with regards to combat rounds/DAs at moderately high haste values.
2. The increase in mobs killed with Glanz is very likely due to the fact that Alma did more damage with Glanz, not the other way around. And in fact, based on # of mobs killed in 1 hour, they WERE NOT KILLING EVERY MOB AS IT WAS SPAWNING.
EXCEPT YOU ARE OFF BY MORE THAN 15% ON THE NUMBER OF MOBS KILLED.
231 in 2 hours. 118 the first hour, 113 the 2nd.
lol2. We both understand hate and enmity mechanics perfectly fine, thanks. As I said in another post (do you even read them, or pick 1 sentence to reply to?), a pld will never hold hate over a sam/war that wants to tank. A mnk/war will also never hold hate over a sam/war that wants to tank, unless the monk is actively trying to with vokes/etc.
Ignoring the fact that mnk/war kills sam/war in merit parties, you criticize me for not reading your posts (which I do), then totally miss the point that THE PALADIN WOULD NOT BE THERE TO TANK. The paladin would be there to provide the party with extra cure 4s and flash after Rushing Stab while DD'ing to the best of their ability.
Christ.
Again: You're off by over 15% on the number of mobs killed. That's not margin of error, kid. They killed a mob every 31-33 seconds. That's enough to clear the area and skew the parse.2. The increase in mobs killed with Glanz is very likely due to the fact that Alma did more damage with Glanz, not the other way around. And in fact, based on # of mobs killed in 1 hour, they WERE NOT KILLING EVERY MOB AS IT WAS SPAWNING.
And paradoxically, having killed more mobs in the first hour speaks to the fact that Pikemen were more often out long enough to pop their wyverns, whereas during the 2nd hour they were not.
I'm only off if you count Wyverns as Mamools. Personally, I don't.
118 - 17 is what. Shit, I know this one, can someone help me please?
And 113 - 13, god, if only I knew how to do math. I'm really bad at math.
As for merit parties, *shrug*, maybe you're an amazing player (I have no clue, you fail at math though). Maybe you do well in merit parties. I know for a fact that I have -never- seen a monk outparse my sam. And BTW, that doesn't mean that SAM > MNK in merit parties, it's all just personal experience (as is yours, and I'd bet a decent bit you've never parsed with a good sam).
As for your amazing conclusion with 2 more wyverns meaning they killed slower, I don't even know what to say, but I can come up with probably what, 10 different reasons as to why there's more wyverns, including but not limited to the fact they may have pulled 2 more pikemen when they were doing more damage?
More pets would actually benefit the glanz. Lower defense to hit harder and deal more damage.
Not necessarily. It certainly can be, depending on the camp and the rest of your party (as has been mentioned here numerous times). If I do merits with my lsmates on DD jobs on birds, I always go /war with no problems.
On the other hand, I did Mamools at the jade camp once and we had 2 pickup DRK/SAM, don't have the parse handy but I know by the end I had something like 50% damage share in the party, died a couple of times on that one. I'd have no qualms in going back there /war with the setup we usually take to birds though, probably just have to forego counterstance to stay on the safe side.
I don't see how /WAR would be a problem in a good merit party. RDM COR BRD and 3 good DDs, or some variation of that. People often treat healers with kid gloves, but they should be able to handle curing 3.5 DDs all with DD subs if they have enough refresh and the mobs are dying fast.
Focus augmentation adds +5% to ATK. So, at 400 ATK, I get 420 ATK with Focus active. If I equip Bandomusha instead of Usukane--422 ATK--I get 443 with Focus active (422 x 5% = 21.1). As far as I can tell, Focus augmentation only considers weapon skill level and equipment. I don't believe there is anything else to the augmentation.Augmented Focus?
I don't know about the Dodge augmentation yet. I suspect either damage reduction or counter bonus, but I have not tried to test either. I'll need to befriend some mandragoras.
Well shit. Is there another parser I could use or do I have no choice but to cut down attack speed to get an accurate reading?1. KParse is inaccurate with regards to combat rounds/DAs at moderately high haste values.
Could try weapons in sky, those are kinda consistent.
Weapons can chain up to ~20s+ from what I remember (Then again that was in 2004 on DRG). Skeles might skew the results with AoE status effects.
Alma: KParser is the only parser that even attempts to calculate multi-attack rates (as far as I know), and sadly, yes, at high haste it becomes very uncertain. Unfortunately I'm in the middle of a rewrite of a lot of its internals, but if I push it maybe I can work on some improvements and push out a new release by this weekend.
Given 55% counter, (trait+merit)Counterstance+Melee Gaiters, Glanzfaust Dodge augmentation adds 5% to counter rate.
59.61% counters in 1014 attacks, using Mourioche in Boyahda. Sushi and Focus in every session assured capped accuracy. Parsing resumed only after engaging, Focus/Counterstance/Dodge were applied before engaging. Parsing suspended when the Dodge StatusTimer reached 0:01.
Hard to find MNKs, no, hard to find WHM+RDM+BRD to make it work right, near impossible anymore.
<Monk> hey all the ToAU camps are taken, lets go to KRT!
<Mages> are you going to sub ninja?
<Monk> hell no that shit is useless for KRT...
<Mages> {See you again!} /campaign tags
idk what mages are like on other servers, but many have gotten quite lazy/stupid on Ragnarok, and no one merits anymore unless its a LS merit pt, campaign/lvl sync has broken the game.