It was released to selected critics, who all said it was surprisingly good. They didn't want the bad press that Transformers got from critics who were overly harsh. I wish no studios would release movies to the press early 'cause you just get a bunch of idiots who don't know what real people really like, telling you what they feel. The whole idea of a "movie critic" is asinine. No two people are going to feel the same way about most movies. I usually take sites like rottentomatoes more seriously than I take Ebert because a general cross section of the populace is much more likely to be right than some dude who watches movies for a living.
my major problem with RT is there is no policing the critics who review a movie bad just to get hits
But this is a flaw common to all bloggers, which is why I presume RT implemented their 'featured reviewers' filter feature which supposedly only picks the sincerest reviewers by reputation. Besides, this is a brainless summer action flick, so expectations of how good this will be are framed in that context. Reviewing movies like this is as simple as a checklist.
Does it have tits? yes/no
Does it have cool fights between ninjas? yes/no
Are the heros likable? yes/no
When you laugh at the script, is it a meanspirited laugh? yes/no
and so on. The bar can't be set that high.
Job is supposed to be taking the entire office to see this on Friday. Probably gonna skip it, I dunno though.
It's like the Movie Doom where it didn't have Hell opening it's gates to unleash demons upon the universe. Think of that regarding the suits for GI Joe. ; ;
I saw a clip on conan for this and I would expect the reviews to start dropping on RT soon. It seems a bit fishy that so few have reviewed it and its just 1-2 days away.
I thought when you go watch a movie with friends/girlfriends/wives, you're there to enjoy the god damn movie. Especially since you KNOW that the movie is going to have a lot of "oh shit it's snake eyes" moments. Especially since you know you wanna see Scarlette in all her red hair glory. Especially since you want to hear the shrill that Cobra makes when he talks. I will enjoy this because it was a cartoon when I was growing up and I always wanted to see them create a cartoon into a live-action cept "masters of the universe" with Dolph Lundgren ugh. But now since movie budgets are enormous, they can make w/e the fuck they want. I'll watch!
For real though. If Cobra Commander is in the movie, he NEEDS that voice. I don't care what anyone says. That voice makes CC.
ROTTEN TOMATOES: Toying With the JOEs: How Do the Characters Match Up?
cobra commander on bottom of page 2
I almost wish they just made this a time piece taking place in the 80's. The Cold War is so much more interesting as a back drop than the war on terror.
Goddamnit that movie was so bad.
there are just not enough words for how bad it was
BAD
going to bed angry now.
loool down to 41 on RT
After reading the bad reviews on RT, it looks like the movie is being rated down for the exact reasons why fans of GI Joe would want to go see the movie.
What did you expect, Casablanca? The movie was incredibly entertaining. Action packed, humor, and it even laughed at itself.
Over at /Film there's an article asking what people thought of the film. This comment made me laugh:
This movie was terrible. It was like a Saturday morning cartoon. Channing Tatum is extremely unlikeable. Looking into his eyes on that big screen all I could see was doucheness and anti-charisma. The whole movie felt 'urrrck', lifeless and stale. The feeling you get standing in a dirty stinking alley while it's raining, and you're trying to eat a hamburger, but the rain is making the bread all soggy, and the rain is dripping down you're nose and you just want this terrible feeling to end - That's what seeing G.I Jo felt like.