I was going to make this a combined transportation thread, but the airship thread was made before I could, so I'll do it this way.
As the forum Gestapo has dictated, this is not wild (baseless) speculation, but at least vaguely rooted in official information.
I'll attempt to strike the tone thusly:
The feeling towards FFXI's chocobo systems are difficult to pin down, at times, but is generally less than positive. Racing is almost universally shit on (with reason), the raising/breeding itself is seen in a better light, but lacks real practicallity, and the whole thing is just seem as an unecessarily insubstantial disappointment. Even in its glowing moments, there's a prevading feeling of 'why bother' with there being superior forms of transportation of money-making.
SE made it clear that FFXIV's chocobos will be different, but what does that mean? Are they going to fix what's broken or completely ditch the concept? I believe they might lean towards the latter, and imo that's a mistake.
Please forgive the use of the ouch word, but WoW's mount system had the strength of accessibility, but always lacked the tactile sensation of actually interacting with your creature. You don't even feed them like hunter pets, you just obtain them and go. That's not necessarily a bad thing, but it was SE's opportinuty to exploit one of WoW's few (admittedly minor) weaknesses.
With all of SE's promises of doing better this time, they may lose things they did right.
XI Wiki



