Scratch the thread entirely. Found a DVI>HDMI adapter for my videocard and a HDMI switcher for $25, lol.

(Basically I was trying to find a way to use two DVI cables on a HDCP monitor with only one DVI-D connector. I just spazzed out and forgot about the DVI-HDMI connector I had, so now I have two HDMI cables and one HDMI to DVI cable.)