
Originally Posted by
BrillCS
Atlantic division seems to be the only one that year in and year out is pretty competitive. The other two aren't usually nearly as close. And back to what we were talking about Ishido. I definitely understand your point when it comes to some of those guys being fourth line pluggers and agitators. But I personally think that by keeping someone along the lines of Maltby or Holmstrom playing as much as they do, the Wings are shooting themselves in the foot by not giving that playing time to the youngsters they have down in Grand Rapids a chance to play.
That's a bit of a double edged sword though. Do you take the 22 year old winger out of Grand Rapids where he's playing 15 - 20 minutes a night and then plunk him on the third line where he might get 10 minutes tops? I think it's worth the risk. Look at Abdelkader and Helm for example. Neither one of them were expected to jump in and contribute much when they played in the playoffs. I think that both of them proved they are ready to play regularly in the NHL and would be able to contribute.
I'm not knocking the older guys who still contribute quite a bit(Cleary, Lidstrom, etc) but I will say that the Maltby's and Holmstrom's are doing nothing more than taking up roster space. Yes they can pass on their wealth of experience to the younger guys, but when they are taking minutes away from them things need to change.
Long story short. Detroit has the experience, familiarity, and talent to make another deep run into the playoffs. But I think they are going to come up short if they match up against the Blackhawks or another similarly up tempo, speedy team now that they are also getting Stanley Cup playoff experience.