We always had atleast 3 usually 4 CS Stunners ~ team of 2 > 20s > single or team of 2 > 20s > team of 2 (20s = wait 20s until next one pops CS) ~ Or If I thought for whatever reason we needed longer to kill him (Lack of drks and/or rngs) had second team wait 30s before using CS~
We also always always killed Fairy Ring and Nan'tina ~ (I have heard of several linkshells skipping one or the other though.)
It's probable your just running into bad luck though. I've never resisted on him (finger gauntlets, nashira, torque, macc), not to say it couldn't happen though.
XI Wiki



