
Originally Posted by
Byrthnoth
Thalassocrat > Mezraq in most situations.
Zaide is confusing. It's definitely better than those two against beasts, but it might be about the same against non-beasts. It's really too bad it wasn't Bird Killer.
So here's how I reason it out:
Zaide requires +25 STP during TP and WS to get a 6-hit. This is pretty easy for DRG, Rose Strap + Rajas + Brutal + /SAM
492 (Mezraq/Thalasso delay) * .97 = ~478
So you've just traded Pole Strap for Sword Strap and picked up 8 Attack in exchange for 2 DEX, 2 VIT, 1 base damage, and Impairs Evasion. It probably evens out as far as DoT and WS goes, assuming your Acc is capped and that 2 DEX wasn't in the dDex=40-50 range for TP or Drakesbane.
VS. Beasts, I'd put:
Zaide > Thalassocrat +1 > Mezraq +1 > Thalassocrat > Mezraq
VS. non-beasts, I'd put:
Thalassocrat +1 > Mezraq +1 > Zaide > Thalassocrat > Mezraq
If you already have a Zaide I wouldn't feel it was gimping you in any situation. Also, because someone may ask, I put Thalasso+1 > Mezraq +1 even though they'll have the same damage 75% of the time because it's still Atk+2-3 vs. Acc+2-3 and Crit+?% and DRG needs Acc more than people like to think.