I wouldn't argue that Tomoe is going to be better than Kaiten in situations where both weapons are good, but I also wouldn't argue that Amano is 150mil worth of damage upgrade, especially when you could have gotten Yoichi for almost the same amount.
Kaiten: Heavily attack modified, 60% STR, 3.0 fTP, Higher attack due to higher skill/meat
Penta: Heavily attack modified, 20% DEX/STR, 5.0 fTP, Piercing damage
They get TP at about the same speed, have about the same base damage (pre-magian upgrades) Amano has higher DoT and much higher attack.
Then again:
Namas Arrow: Heavily RAtk modified, 40% STR/AGI, 2.75 fTP, and all the benefits of being a ranged attack (half level correction, double fSTR) along with enough of an RAcc boost in the aftermath that SAMs can land it while essentially just whoring RAtk and mods.
Edit: Oh yeah, and the shit is practically hateless.
Doubleedit: And double yeah, you can also fire them off faster than either of the above options by quite a bit. 5-hit it with Soboro and it's somewhere around 2.3 attack rounds to 100TP if I remember right. ~75-100% increase in WS frequency.
Think whoring RAtk is gay? Well, on HNMs you'll never have to worry about hate and suffer half the pDIF penalty due to level correction that an Amano does. Merit party setup event? You can do a ton of damage without taking hate by just riding Hasso and tossing out Namas's like there's no tomorrow. Yoichi wins.
I still remember being pissed at a Yoichi SAM we had because he kept WSing my slept birds because they were at a more optimal range for him. Mostly because the bird would wake up and chase the bard.
XI Wiki



