Gearing Namas isnt exactly rocket science. the whole point of the thread was to discuss the viability of 5hit instead of 6hit. Trading some haste for a reduced swing to 100tp.
If you'd actually read the thread and managed to pick out the useful posts that were dotted among the usual BG bickering, then you'd realise that it was a pretty informative thread and I wouldnt have to call you stupid for coming in and basically saying what everyone else has said.
Just because you have Yoichi, it doesn't mean it's a better relic.
By this definition, then G.horn is the only "game breaking" relic. Followed by exal and apoc. Suggesting that an Aegis is in any way game breaking is just laughable. It holds a slight advantage when taking magic damage, but besides that, I can think of absolutly no situation where somebody has only said "if only our tank had an aegis

"
Whereas Amano is a significant step up from Hagun. (talking lv75 ffxi here). Kaiten alone ensures the significant boost. I didn't want to believe it at first, but even when using Gekko, Amano was at an advantage. It was similar performance to 5-hit Tomoe on birds, that alone should speak volumes about how good it is. yes, yoichi is better in these situations with full buffs, but it's usefulness drops off alot quicker than Amano's. Suggesting Amano is a marginal upgrade from Hagun (still talking in lv75 terms here) only reveals your ignorance on the subject.
This paragraph is barely legible, but what I think you're trying to suggest is relic weapons can't be compared on merit level mobs because another job would be better? then something about aegis.
As far as I can tell, Aegis is the most completed relic simply because back in 2003 and 2004, pld was the only available tank. because of this, linkshells were more inclined to sponser the main tank of the linkshell for a relic that would, as they saw it, benefit the whole linkshell. The same mentality applies with G.horn.
What is Aegis used for these days? reducing magic damage and blocking a little more damage when you're trying to cast Ichi.
So SAM can't tank? Again, you beg to be called stupid, but I'll refrain.
SAM can tank excellently on a wide range of mobs. Unlike traditional tanks; PLD, NIN, RDM... it can do a significant amount of damage while tanking.
And lv80 has changed everything. the conclusion of this thread was at lv75, 5hit was unviable due to dropping too many essential stats in other areas. However, with lv80 and the associated new Items and higher skills, 5-hit is not only viable but significantly better. Failure explained it all (to me because I didnt know about the new items, i might add) in the relic augment thread.
One more thing... Before you post your next reply, Copy and paste it into word and correct all the red and green squiggly lines. Thanks, that'll save us all having to copy it into google translate for Double Dutch to understand what you're trying to say.