
Originally Posted by
Ryko
Okay I'm gonna go down the list quickly and say where I disagree and why.
I'm gonna stick to the criteria that I can only imagine formed your top tier list, which I'm assuming is the poster's ability to antagonize others (Kiarax being the main exception to that assumption). With that in mind the only person who antagonizes others as much as the rest of the people on the top tier list that didn't make it close is perm, which is why your claim of not being biased is off, skewed, or incorrect.
TSM was rather high tier when he posted but he doesn't really do that anymore so just due to not keeping up he's high at the very best, if not mid. Love the guy, but homie doesn't keep up.
Aside from BRP the high tier posters are mostly people who tend to be buddy buddy with everyone. Tyven is a mid tier poster, though I will give him the top of mid thanks to the slant movement that happened all around BG. But if creating fads etc were a criteria for quality, I'd be a lot higher, and I don't think I should be. Abandon is rather glaringly missing from this section. Moots probably belongs in mid for the same reason tsm needs to drop.
Mid Tier is consistent. I personally think perm should be moved up but only due to the reasons that I stated previously. Residue is definitely potential for high tier though, we'll see where this meat things goes. (twss) Beckwin is missing from either mid or high tier depending on criteria.
Abandon being low tier is a fucking farce, guy has contributed a number of long winding rather fully entertaining topics and was a consistently fun presence amongst spam posters. Again, your criteria is skewed if you think otherwise.
I think Ivve (by herself) being low tier is also a farce, girl is a consistent mid tier poster when left to her own devices.
Airenn is pretty much bottom tier in terms of posting.
I'd just combine low and shit tier.
And lastly you need to work on making a tier list because the names should be in order of position in their section. This forces you to decide who the best poster is sadly but it's there for a reason.