
Originally Posted by
SnickySnacks
Niiro, I disagree with your conjecture. Having leveled MNK to 80 and solod all my skillups since then, I'm almost 100% sure that your natural counter is not checked during p.counter, rather as I have said, p.counter counters 1-3 attacks, with attacks that bypass p.counter counting as an attack.
In addition, even using counterstance I've yet to see more than 3 attacks countered and still see the normal 1-3 counters from p.counter. While I have no idea if counterstance affects hits that bypass p.counter, given that I'm still seeing a normal distribution of 1-3 counters (I'm not seeing more triple counters with counterstance) I don't believe counterstance or natural counter affects p.counter at all.
Test it yourself. Mobs that you rarely counter you will now counter around 95% between using p.counter and having p.counter wear. Rarely, a mob's swing will bypass p.counter. Even more rarely, a mob's swing will cause p.counter to wear.
At no point is your "natural counter" or "counterstance" checked.