I was a hardcore FFXI player for years, and I was one of those people that reserved the special edition of FFXIV when it came out. I played it for a few months and tried my hardest to enjoy it. Eventually, I realized there was just nothing there to enjoy and I gave up. I think it was in January or February. I begrudgingly left because I didn't feel this title had anything to do with the FF franchise, and my fanboy powers weren't enough to make me enjoy it.
Today, I got a "we want to win you back" email from SE. I haven't thought about this game in nearly a year, and I was actually surprised it's still being worked on. This email is jam packed with stuff telling me how much better the game is now.
Is it really? I last played before the big disaster in Japan caused the servers to go offline and all that. I think I got a DoW class to like rank 40 or something, a craft around r40 (I think blacksmith?) and physical level 50. EDIT: Oh cool, I have a signature. Guess I was pretty close.
Is this game really to the point that there's more to do than the same leves over and over or are they just desperately trying to win back people like me?
XI Wiki


