I've done a bit more testing (not extensively) based on a theory about what HS Soul Plates do. I have seemed to get far better, rarer skills with the HQ. I got 2 Instant Phalanxes from Ominous weapons with 12 HQ plates and no Undead Killers or nonleveled traits, but 1 Instant Phalanx from 24 NQ plates with a lot of Undead Killers and an INT+25. The reason we didn't notice before is because we didn't know what was rare.
Thoughts?
XI Wiki

