So this is really just speculation until I get to try some more next weekend, but I noticed something odd last night. I was at Beluslan Roof gathering the Carp-somethings for the quest in Red Mane Cavern. They are 345 skill and I was 344 so I grabbed a few Anathe just to hit 345. I started at the east end of the river with the fish and worked west to the pond, gathering maybe a dozen nodes. In those 36 or less gathers I went from 345 to 350 skill. Maybe the planets aligned for those couple minutes, but I haven't raised gathering skill that fast since, ever, I think. I had the idea that maybe your skill rate is based of how much exp from gathering you have received, since that fits with the whole lower skill items raise you slower, and could possibly explain this. Like maybe every skill level has a hidden exp total required for skill leveling up, and the 2x exp boost to gathering makes that faster too. And if that is the case, what about crafting skill?
/theorycrafting
XI Wiki


